Alexander Halser

Problem solved. It wasn't the permissions, but a native NSToolbar control. This toolbar contained two NSToolbarSidebarTrackingSeparator items, which were used to create a vertical separator bar on the toolbar. While this had worked before, it's illegal for macOS 15. Only one of this item type is permitted.

Signed and notarized, as explained above. Shouldn't that be sufficient?

I have a Delphi FMX app that runs fine on anything from macOS Big Sure to Sonoma. Just on the latest Sequoia release, it doesn't start. It seems, that this has to do with new sandbox restrictions. Any ideas what to change in the entitlements to make it run on Sequoia? The app is signed and notarized, compiled with Delphi 11.3. This is the crash log I get on Sequoia (from a different mac, not my development machine): 2024-11-07 08:43:02.786318 <Notice>: Last log repeated 1 times 2024-11-07 08:43:02.785852 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018) <Notice>: internal event: WILL_SPAWN, code = 0 2024-11-07 08:43:02.785996 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018) <Notice>: service state: spawn scheduled 2024-11-07 08:43:02.785999 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018) <Notice>: service state: spawning 2024-11-07 08:43:02.786053 <Notice>: Coalition Cache Hit: app<application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018(501)> [985] 2024-11-07 08:43:02.786105 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018) <Notice>: launching: launch job demand 2024-11-07 08:43:02.787814 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: xpcproxy spawned with pid 1131 2024-11-07 08:43:02.787872 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: internal event: SPAWNED, code = 0 2024-11-07 08:43:02.787875 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: service state: xpcproxy 2024-11-07 08:43:02.787956 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: internal event: SOURCE_ATTACH, code = 0 2024-11-07 08:43:02.813870 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: service state: running 2024-11-07 08:43:02.813881 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: internal event: INIT, code = 0 2024-11-07 08:43:02.813884 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: job state = running 2024-11-07 08:43:02.814097 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: Successfully spawned SnipSVG[1131] because launch job demand 2024-11-07 08:43:02.845832 (pid/1131 [SnipSVG]) <Notice>: uncorking exec source upfront 2024-11-07 08:43:02.845882 (pid/1131 [SnipSVG]) <Notice>: created 2024-11-07 08:43:03.355264 (pid/1131 [SnipSVG]) <Notice>: shutting down 2024-11-07 08:43:03.355286 (pid/1131 [SnipSVG]) <Notice>: cleaning up 2024-11-07 08:43:03.355364 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: exited due to exit(217), ran for 567ms 2024-11-07 08:43:03.355370 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: service state: exited 2024-11-07 08:43:03.355381 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: internal event: EXITED, code = 0 2024-11-07 08:43:03.355386 (gui/501/application.SnipSVG.16305011.16305018 [1131]) <Notice>: job state = exited ... My entitlements list:

The error reporting solution from JustAddCode that you mention in your tutorial does work reasonably well. While the line numbers are pretty odd, it at least delivers the function name. I was able to solve the problem on macOS with this tool.

Bringing up this topic again... I have managed to get a stack trace report on macOS, but I am not entirely sure what to do with it. There is a Windows app called "addr2line.exe", which I assume is supposed to parse the file that contains the debug symbols (for macOS that would be MyAppName.dSYM, right?). Then I have to feed it the addresses that I got from the error log. And it should return unit and line number where the error actually occurred. However, addr2line.exe doesn't seem to understand the format of the .dSYM file. Is this because it expects a Windows executable? Probably yes. Do I have to do this on the Mac with a macOS version of this tool? If yes, which is it? My stack trace looks like this: OS Version: macOS (Version 11.6.7) Product Version: 1.0.0 Product Name: FmxApp Platform: OSXARM64 Config: Debug DateTime: 31_10_24 10_41_00 Log-File: FmxApp-31_10_24-10_41_00.log Stack trace: 00000001024C8000:000000010254298C: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102D1EC24: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102A20750: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102A85428: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102A20D98: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C8A50C: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C2A308: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C2A66C: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C17394: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:00000001024CB438: FmxApp 0000000192AA5000:0000000192C69DC8: AppKit 0000000192AA5000:0000000192C6915C: AppKit 0000000192AA5000:0000000192C68034: AppKit 0000000192AA5000:0000000192F35194: AppKit 0000000192AA5000:0000000192AD78A0: AppKit 00000001024C8000:00000001024CB260: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C10CCC: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C10C14: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102C7E464: FmxApp 00000001024C8000:0000000102D1EF24: FmxApp Modules: AppKit: FmxApp:304f03e2f8d59eb00757a868fa075d26 Title: Application Error Message: Access violation at address 0000000102D1EE30, accessing address 0000000000000000

The Windows D2D implementation in FMX in FMX.Canvas.D2D.pas always assumes a premultiplied alpha. This is probably the source of the problem. Anders Melander can perhaps comment on that with more expertise than I have. D2D1_ALPHA_MODE (dcommon.h) - Win32 apps | Microsoft Learn One option to solve it would be to write a TCustomBitmapCodec for raw PNG data and load/save your PNGs through this codec exclusively. If SKIA is an option for you, install SKIA and enable it for your app. SKIA effectively implements its own canvas and its own image codecs, leaving your PNG file as it is. I tested your example image with SKIA enabled and the bitmap stays the same, no matter how often it is loaded and saved. Obviously, the SKIA codecs do a better job.

IMO the gestures are designed for real touchscreens and not for touchpads. I believe this has never worked with touchpads. Anyway, I have implemented a solution for myself by patching FMX.Platform.Mac, which was already patched anyway to work around the Sonoma scaling bug on MacOS. This is certainly not for everyone, but works like a charm. It uses the Angle parameter for an alternative zoom gesture (Angle is used in rotation gestures, for zoom it's always zero). Your app needs to respond to this accordingly. Most importantly, it doesn't break regular zoom gestures coming from real touch screens. procedure TFMXViewBase.magnifyWithEvent(event: NSEvent); var ... begin ... if FGestureControl <> nil then begin LTouches := event.touchesMatchingPhase(NSTouchPhaseTouching, NSView(Super)); if LTouches.count >= 2 then begin LTouchesArray := LTouches.allObjects; LTouch := TNSTouch.Wrap(LTouchesArray.objectAtIndex(0)); LDeviceSize := LTouch.deviceSize; FEventInfo.Distance := 0; //reset the distance // Find the greatest distance between the touches. for I := 0 to LTouches.count - 2 do begin LTouch := TNSTouch.Wrap(LTouchesArray.objectAtIndex(I)); LPoint := LTouch.normalizedPosition; for J := 1 to LTouches.count - 1 do begin LTouch := TNSTouch.Wrap(LTouchesArray.objectAtIndex(J)); LPoint2 := LTouch.normalizedPosition; Distance := Round(Sqrt(Sqr(LPoint.x * LDeviceSize.width - LPoint2.x * LDeviceSize.width) + Sqr(LPoint.y * LDeviceSize.height - LPoint2.y * LDeviceSize.height))); if Distance > FEventInfo.Distance then FEventInfo.Distance := Distance; end; FEventInfo.GestureID := igiZoom; if Supports(FGestureControl, IGestureControl, GestureObj) then GestureObj.CMGesture(FEventInfo); FEventInfo.Flags := []; end end {ECS/ALEX} else if LTouches.count = 0 then begin FEventInfo.Distance := 0; FEventInfo.Angle := event.magnification; FEventInfo.GestureID := igiZoom; if Supports(FGestureControl, IGestureControl, GestureObj) then GestureObj.CMGesture(FEventInfo); FEventInfo.Flags := []; end; end {ECS/ALEX} else //send the message up the responder chain NSView(Super).magnifyWithEvent(event); end;

No, I haven't. But the magnifyWithEvent comes reliably and this is what Delphi actually evaluates. I am not that deep into native MacOS development, so I rather stay with the methods that Delphi already implements.

The problem is in FMX.Platform.Mac: procedure TFMXViewBase.magnifyWithEvent(event: NSEvent); var ... begin ... if FGestureControl <> nil then begin LTouches := event.touchesMatchingPhase(NSTouchPhaseTouching, NSView(Super)); {ECS/ALEX Here comes our problem: LTouches.count is zero, that's why the gesture event is not fired. I assume that we have to deal with "event.magnification" to determine "FEventInfo.Distance". } if LTouches.count >= 2 then begin LTouchesArray := LTouches.allObjects; LTouch := TNSTouch.Wrap(LTouchesArray.objectAtIndex(0)); LDeviceSize := LTouch.deviceSize; ... I am currently experimenting with the event.magnification value (which is a float value), to match FEventInfo.Distance in a way that the example from the official docs keeps working the way it promises, but doesn't. However, I have a hard time to believe that this has never worked. If Emba has dedicated examples, there must have been a time when this did work properly. It perhaps depends on the MacOS version. My own version of MacOS that I'm using for testing is relatively old (Big Sur), with a second Mac used by one of my colleagues running Sonoma. The gesture is not fired on either machine, but may have been working on OS versions < Big Sur. If it has never worked with touchpad gestures, it might have worked and still work with a real touch screen. Is anyone competent to comment on that - does the igiZoom gesture work as advertised with touch screen Mac (we don't have them here, so I cannot test this)?

Yes, rotate works as described in the docs. Zoom and pan do not. There's no event at all for these. The pan gesture (swiping up or down with 2 fingers) obviously gets translated into a mouse wheel message.

So, it's officially broken, despite documentation says the opposite? Gestures in FireMonkey - RAD Studio (embarcadero.com)

I wonder if you found a solution for this. The rotate gesture seems to be the only gesture that works with a MacOS trackpad. Everything else - simply broken.

Sure. Winapi.Windows.pas and SetWindowLong would be difficult to compile anyway for MacOS, iOS and Android 😉 Are there any other negative side effects known?

Partial answer: in VCL the behavior is triggered by MainFormOnTaskbar := true; More detailed answer: it is the param WS_EX_APPWINDOW in the window GWL_EXSTYLE that makes the window appear (automatically set by MainFormOnTaskbar). In FMX, the main form can be made visible in the selection list by setting the form's (Windows) window handle manually: procedure TForm1.Button1Click(Sender: TObject); var WND: HWND; begin wnd := FmxHandleToHWND(self.handle); SetWindowLong(wnd, GWL_EXSTYLE, GetWindowLong(wnd, GWL_EXSTYLE) or WS_EX_APPWINDOW); //now the form is visible in the "Also snap..." list end; New question: Any known downside or side effects due to this modification?

When pressing the Windows key plus the right or left arrow key simultaneously, the window is moved to fill the right or left half of the screen, respectively. This works for FMX forms as well, out of the box. At least with D11, not sure about older FMX versions. However, when you release the Win key, Windows usually offers (if enabled in global settings) a list of windows to fill the other half of the screen. And this is the issue I am wondering about: A VCL form is shown in this "also snap..." list. An FMX form is not shown. I assume that either a param in CreateParams is responsible for this behavior, or a Windows message needs to be handled to enable it (which is implemented in VCL but not in FMX for Windows). Does anyone know what causes the FMX window to be hidden and how to overcome it?