GabrielMoraru

What I am trying to say here (and raise an alarm) is that I have seen this trend where AI lacks (compared with other languages) when you try to use it for Delphi (VCL). Initially I thought it was only an impression, but later tests (for example, generating a full program with Replit in Delphi and then in other languages) turned an "impression" into a confirmation. FMX is out of the discussion. As Windows OS is losing market share, I hope that Embarcadero will focus on FMX. I understand that most paying customers have huge systems built only for Windows, but that will not last forever. So, 1) We need more libraries/code on GitHub (etc.) to train the AI (I published some of my libraries on GitHub in the last two years; more to come). 2) We need tools like Replit or Copilot for VS that can better integrate with the IDE (I am writing one, but I am a beginner at OTA) 3) We need to look more into the future, ditching the VCL for FMX (here Embarcadero has the last word). Now, the AI is already good at writing all by itself small web applications. If AI will get far superior at writing medium (and in the next 2-4 years even million SLOC sized) applications, Delphi will lose the battle. It is a positive feedback loop: the better the AI gets at JS, C# (etc., the less Delphi code will be out there.

The documentation claim that the new API (since Delphi 11) allows access to the compiler messages. I am working on this... but slowly as the weekend is gone... 😞 > well, tested on few old IDEs, up to XE8, if that will help then i can search for that fun project and try to adjust it for you. That would be interesting to see since I will have to make it work also for users that do not have the new OTA API (Delphi 11) Thanks 🙂

I think the most important part for my plugin is the capability to interact with the compilation/debugging system so the AI can automatically check for compilation errors.

I want to create an IDE plugin like Copilot for Visual Studio or like Cursor. I already started with OTA but now I wonder if it would have been better to go for NTA (Native Tools API). NTA seems more brittle but also more complete (and way less boiler plate code). Opinions?

I know... I know... (On the other hand I sold all my Tesla stocks).

I see that the question is in the VCL domain, where I like Grok. ______ But I can also tell you about FMX where the best AI is... drum roll please.................................................. none. They all suck terribly as FMX. Probably not their fault. Probably because of lack of code on GitHub.... 😞 And what the AI does when it does not know the answer to a question?????? It hallucinates things. So, all your queries MUST contain "check your answer for hallucinations" .

Hi. Two comments here: 1. Library description Many libraries use big words to describe what they do. In the end you don't get it - unless you invest some time to look deep into the code or documentation. So, maybe you can "dumb down" a bit the project description. Maybe something like: "if you use this library right now in your Delphi project your will be able to xyz", where xyz is the most important feature of your library. It is like when you go to the store and you see a can and you instantly know that inside is tomato soup. Then add the rest of the "complicated" description 🙂 PS: I read the documentation and now I think I get it. But it took a while. 2. asynchronous In general when I use the AI, I ask then I wait for the answer. Is there something you can do if you work in asynchronous mode, while waiting for the answer from the AI? Maybe starting a second request??? If no, then there is no point in using asynchronous. Great library! Thanks for sharing.

> The GitHub link at the end does not work That's just WordPress being dumb... It won't let me insert links to GitHub. It tries to present a screenshot of the repository and fails. I had to type the address manually. PS: I also have a website generator - much much better and stable than WordPress.... but... not the pages generated are not that pretty. I have to integrate some Boostrap support. One day I will make also that one open source 🙂 _______________ This comes from a promise that I made a while ago that I will "free" some of my private libraries. So, as the time allows, more and more code will be released.

I just released my NCG library as open source on GitHub. The full library description and documentation here. Discussions: I think it might be the only NGS Pascal library out there... The program works quite fine but it speed is not impressive... on the other hand is does not have any optimization and it is single threaded. If you have multiple patterns to look into the "big" image, each one could go into a thread. On a CPU with 12 cores, like mine, this code could easily behave as and OCR 🙂 Pre-compiled demo program also available. Enjoy. ____ Related to image processing: You will find also some basic image processing code in my LightSaber lib. There is another library that I will make it also open source that adds metadata to an image, so you can autorotate it based on exif, add "stars" to it (how much you like, it), pregenerated thumbnail (to save some time CPU next time you show it), etc. So, stay tuned... 🙂 ____ PS: On Git hub, vote only the libraries you like 🙂 🙂 🙂 I invest time in those that get votes 🙂

Hi Marci, Next year I might come with you. We talk next year in April... 🙂

July will start soon... let's see how Delphi will appear in the top....

I think, under the new "bug report" portal it is not possible to "me too" (vote) anymore. 😞

@Pat Heuvel- Thanks. I tried the (relatively) new version from github and it works!

Somebody suggested ProcessMonitor, but there is a better tool for this: PE Explorer (although not freeware). It will show you a red dot like this where the dependency fails. There is also Dependency Walker 2.2 (freeware, but kind of old) but it freezes with Delphi BPLs.

Thanks. But this is way beyond that. I think that under certain conditions, the linker simply does not put the debug information into the DCU or EXE file. Or if it is there, the debugger cannot use it. My environment is identical with Lars' except " current user has local admin rights". It is quite random... Today works, tomorrow not. Restarting the IDE helped in 2-3 cases but not in other 10-15. Until now only the code in packages (dpk) was not available for debugging. Once, I rebuilt all packages in a certain order and then I was able to debug again. Friday was the first time when it happen in the project (dpr) itself. But as I said... suddenly it fixed itself so I cannot experiment anymore. The DProj files are very old and I have seen strange lines in there. Lines that are not in a fresh DProj file. I tried to remove those lines one by one, trying to find the offending one. This (broken DProj file) is only a supposition. Until now I strongly believed that it has something to do with the package. But Friday I removed every reference to any external units from the dpr file (except VCL.Dialogs and VCL.forms), cleaned up the DCU folder and it still happened. So, IT IS NOT related to packages. There was only a ShowMessage in the DPR file and it still won't stop there, at that line. uses //FastMM4, vcl.Forms, vcl.Dialogs; begin //Application.Initialize; //Application.MainFormOnTaskbar := True; ShowMessage('Worked!'); // Breakpoint //Application.CreateForm(TForm1, Form1); //Application.Run; end. ______ Normally the exe file is 55MB, and the size is not coming from internal resources and images but from code 🙂 I backed up the exe file and the DCU folder, now that debugging works. I will wait until it doesn't and I will compare the binary files, see if they are smaller.