THttpCli get request fail with 404 Bad Request result

[drazde 0]

Hi,

I use THttpCli component (ICS v8.61) for downloading files.

It works well in many case, but when I try pass a parameter with space (encoding with "+" or "%20") I have the error 400 Bad Request

 

Why?

What can I do?

 

PS: if I put the url in a browser, the request is successful

text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 => CONSEGNA Attestazione avvenuta pubblicazione avviso selezione infermiere.eml
Location = http://192.168.2.221/cbadoc/upload/2019/08/14/CONSEGNA Attestazione avvenuta pubblicazione avviso selezione infermiere.eml
URL = http://192.168.2.221/cbadoc/download.php?file=CONSEGNA+Attestazione+avvenuta+pubblicazione+avviso+selezione+infermiere.eml&id=20878&liv1=2019&liv2=08&liv3=14
Document = CONSEGNA Attestazione avvenuta pubblicazione avviso selezione infermiere.eml
RequestDone, no error. Status = 400
Request Failed !
StatusCode   = 400
ReasonPhrase = Bad Request

 

[Angus Robertson 574]

The server has decided it does not like your parameter encoding, but you don't say you how you do it.   Generally, you encode to UTF8 first, then use IcsUrlEncode for each parameter, then combine the parameters.  But there are variations on URL encoding, the latest beta has a new strict parameter for Twitter which is very fussy. 

 

The better way is to change your application to use TSslHttpRest component, which has RestParams that do all this stuff for you, mostly correctly.  . But update to at least V8.64 first, or even the overnight zip, there have been a lot of changes this year. 

 

Angus

 

[Virgo 18]

Since it is plain http you can use Wireshark to check, what is different in network request comparing browser and you program.

[Fr0sT.Brutal 900]

+1 for comparing to browser. Moreover, you don't even need Wireshark, just the browser's Dev tools with which you even can modify requests before sending.

[drazde 0]

I know, this isn't a good solution, but with TDownloadURL component I don't have this problem in this cases....

I use this component only for downloading file that have params with space and all other with THttpCli.

 

I don't want use always TDownloadURL because it have many other problems...

[Angus Robertson 574]

THttpCli does not encode any parameters, you added that coding, so if the URL does not work you need to correct your code as I suggested yesterday.

 

Angus

 

[drazde 0]

4 hours ago, Angus Robertson said:

THttpCli does not encode any parameters, you added that coding, so if the URL does not work you need to correct your code as I suggested yesterday.

 

Angus

 

I have update ICS component with the latest (v8.65), I use UTF8Encode and then IcsUrlEncode (on the filename parameter the other are merely numbers) but nothing...

 

I remain the better solution is pass the parameters in post (not in get like now), so I think I will talk with my colleague for change it.

Thanks for your answers

[Angus Robertson 574]

URL encoding for GET and POST is the same,  although POST may accept Json or XML instead. 

 

Don't like + for space, should always be %20. The + originates from browser form fields with application/x-www-form-urlencoded MIME POST content, and should not be used in URLs or parameters.

 

Angus