How should spaces after a comment be handled by the formatter

[dummzeuch 1515]

There are currently some unit tests for the GExperts code formatter that fail.

It all depends on how spaces after comments {comment} or (*comment*) are handled.

 

A How should the code formatter handle the following code:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment} SomeStatement;
end;

A1 Keep the space after the comment:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment} SomeStatement;
end;

A2 Remove the space after the comment:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment}SomeStatement;
end;

 

B what about this code:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment}SomeStatement;
end;

B1 should the formatter leave it as is?

B2 should it insert a space, so it gets changed into:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment} SomeStatement;
end;

 

C what about this code with multiple spaces after the comment:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment}     SomeStatement;
end;

C1 should the formatter remove the spaces:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment}SomeStatement;
end;

C2 or should it reduce them to one space:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment} SomeStatement;
end;

C3 or should it leave them as them as they are:

procedure bla;
begin
  {some comment}     SomeStatement;
end;

 

The current code will always remove the spaces, so its A2, B1 and C1.

 

I'm tending towards keeping the number of spaces as they are, that would be A1, B1 and C3.

 

I'm definitely not going to make this configurable. I wouldn't even know how to describe this configuration option.

Edited October 1, 2022 by dummzeuch

[Attila Kovacs 631]

13 minutes ago, dummzeuch said:

I wouldn't even know how to describe this configuration option.

why not?

 

 

you could name it "The option I didn't want to implement #4223"

 

 

Edited October 1, 2022 by Attila Kovacs

[baka0815 12]

I would also prefer a setting:

1. No space

2. Space

3. Line break

4. leave untouched

 

I personally would prefer the "1 space" variant, but I would also not want to have a comment on the left of a statement.

I would prefer the comment above or on the right.

Edited October 10, 2022 by baka0815

[uligerhardt 18]

I think leaving the spaces as is (C3) may be the least annoying solution.

[Sourcemaker 0]

Hi,

the leave untouched option or disable all spacing is needed fot me.

Is there any option?

[eivindbakkestuen 47]

On 10/1/2022 at 8:38 PM, dummzeuch said:

A How should the code formatter handle the following code:

Throw an error because the line starts with a comment.

[Ian Branch 128]

If they must code like that, :-(, make it one space after the comment.

[corneliusdavid 220]

Personally, I think a space after the comment makes it a little more readable.

So I would opt for A1, B2, C2.

 

But more importantly, I think comments should follow code or be on a separate line--I think comments before code on the same line break the vertical continuity of a block of code, causing the statement to be missed when the eye scans down a page.

Therefore, like baka0815, I would much prefer a line-break option to move the statement to the next line.